Here Be Pirates (Don’t shoot, just sail faster)

At the Frankfurt Tools of Change one-day conference last week, Brian O’Leary presented the results, to date, of a study into the impact of piracy on book sales. It generated quite a little storm, helped along by some misunderstandings. So I recommend reading Brian’s level-headed response to it all. The study itself needs the participation of more publishing houses, and let’s hope that more join in.

The most important thing about the study is that it is a study, an attempt to gather some real data. As Brian pointed out to me afterwards, we may all differ on how we interpret the data, but let’s gather some in the first place. It’s a lot more useful than speculation and anecdotal evidence.

If I had a list more susceptible to piracy (EBW does very little publishing, and much of it is open-access) I would want to approach piracy like I should any competitor. I’d want to understand it in detail: why it happens, who does it, and how it affects us and our markets, so that we can figure out how to compete with it, even if it means putting some of our own books into the fray as guinea pigs and canaries.

So until we have more data to go on, perhaps we should treat a pirated copy as a competitor’s product. Just do better: deliver more conveniently and efficiently, experiment constantly, and draw customers to legitimate retail by adding social value, building relationships with and among readers.

There will be other, creative ways to outrun piracy, I’m sure. At the end of this month I’m attending the UK Department of Culture, Media and Sport’s C&binet Forum, and I’m looking forward to seeing what ideas emerge there.

1 thought on “Here Be Pirates (Don’t shoot, just sail faster)

  1. Hi Arthur: I am taking an Internet Highway roadtrip, so to speak. Stopping by my tweeps actual blogs for a change (rather than simply chatting with them on Twitter). So happy to see another call for intelligent discussion of the piracy issue(s). When people get caught up in pro- or anti-DRM shouting matches, they can sometimes forget that they’re really on the same side of an anti-piracy debate. I’m possibly as guilty as anyone else who has participated in this shouting match. (yes, i have used the phrase “DRM Sucks” on more than one occasion.) But, it’s not – or shouldn’t be — a matter of being for or against DRM, but being for a solution that protects the rights (and revenues)of authors and publishers without disrupting the buying and/or borrowing experiences of legitimate readers. So, thanks for shedding some constructive light on the topic. ~ Kat

Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.